The San Francisco 49ers did not release guard Laken Tomlinson in the 2022 free agency period because they undervalued him. Their decision was primarily due to financial constraints, as they couldn’t afford to keep him. Despite earning a Pro Bowl selection in his last season with the team, Tomlinson signed a three-year contract with the New York Jets for an average of $13.3 million—significantly higher than what San Francisco was willing to offer.
Although Tomlinson had one year left on his contract, the Jets chose to release him to create salary cap space, saving approximately $8.1 million.
As highlighted by ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler, Tomlinson rarely sat out games, starting every match in his two seasons with the Jets and maintaining a streak since the 2017 season, only missing the regular season opener due to his recent trade to the 49ers.
However, Tomlinson’s performance declined during his time with the Jets. Pro Football Focus reported his career-low overall (55.0) and pass-blocking (60.6) grades for the past season, with 51 pressures allowed—a career-high and eighth-most among all offensive linemen.
In contrast, during his tenure with San Francisco, Tomlinson never allowed more than 39 pressures in a single season. Furthermore, only one 49ers player—right guard Colton McKivitz—exceeded Tomlinson’s pressures (59) and sacks allowed (9) this past season.
Tomlinson also faced challenges in run blocking with the Jets, never achieving a Pro Football Focus season grade above 50.0. While a change of system may have contributed to his struggles, the question arises about how well he would fit back with his former team.
Since Tomlinson’s departure, Aaron Banks has taken over as the 49ers’ starting left guard. Banks, though receiving less-than-ideal Pro Football Focus grades, has the team’s confidence in his continued improvement.
Reacquiring Tomlinson could potentially mean reshuffling the offensive line, with either Banks or Tomlinson moving to the right side. However, considering Jon Feliciano’s impressive performance, especially in pass protection, he could be a valuable asset if retained in free agency.
Ultimately, Tomlinson’s return to the 49ers would depend on his willingness to consider a position change and the financial terms offered. If another team is willing to offer more in free agency, the 49ers may not engage in a bidding war. While San Francisco is in need of offensive line upgrades, they may explore more economical options in the upcoming draft.
