usatsi_19375799_168390362_lowres

coI have a favorable opinion of Tua Tagovailoa, but I’m not a blindly loyal “Tuanon” who believes he can do no wrong. Likewise, I’m not a “Tua-hater.” I believe Tua should receive a contract extension this year, but my perspective is nuanced.

During a 12-hour drive over the weekend, I contemplated Tua’s expected extension and arrived at a conclusion. While Tua is a good quarterback, he falls short of greatness. He can lead in yardage, maintain a positive touchdown-interception ratio, and be in MVP discussions, but there’s a catch. Tua needs support, and quality support comes at a cost, which the Dolphins are expected to allocate towards his new deal.

Speculation suggests Tua’s contract might match or surpass Joe Burrow’s, a notion I find excessive. In my view, Burrow is overpaid, and Tua, despite playing better than Herbert, should not be valued at $52.5 million annually. I propose a more reasonable figure, around $50 million per season, with a guarantee of approximately $100 million. If the Dolphins perceive Tua as an injury risk, he should consider accepting what he can get.

Tua’s success relies on strong receivers and a robust running game. While he exhibits leadership off the field, on-field inconsistency during critical moments doesn’t justify a top-tier salary. The Dolphins must balance paying Tua adequately with the need to afford talented players on both sides of the ball.

The Five Biggest Miami Dolphins Needs Heading Into the Combine - Sports Illustrated Miami Dolphins News, Analysis and More

My suggested approach is to pay Tua around $50 million per year, guarantee $100 million, and structure the deal with a backloaded arrangement. Including a retirement clause is essential, and reassessing the situation in four years when Tua’s performance is clearer seems prudent.

Despite my reservations, I don’t advocate for letting Tua go or trading him. He possesses great potential and occasional flashes of brilliance. However, until he consistently proves himself, a substantial payday isn’t warranted.

Crucially, the Dolphins hold leverage. They can insist on Tua playing under the $24 million fifth-year option. Tua, without long-term security, must consider the Dolphins’ offer, proving his worth on the field. If he achieves significant success, a renegotiation in three seasons could then position him as the highest-paid QB. The Dolphins, I believe, should avoid repeating the mistakes made by the Bengals and Chargers in overvaluing their quarterbacks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *